The Sacrificial Cat?

The Sacrificial Cat? is a "Who done it?" crime written for Years 6 - 8. It can run from 1 to 5 days. The unit is almost self sufficient, requiring minimal assistance from the hosting school.

Each group of three or four students is given an evidence kit and using their ingenuity and the material contained in the kit, they are required to solve the crime. It challenges students to employ clear thinking and use problem solving skills using forensic science as the vehicle.

All groups work on the same crime but there are over 20 unique solutions making it very difficult for students to find the solution from other groups.

Students require some access to an Excel file on computers and some access to basic science equipment.

After working on the problem, students may "know" who the criminal is. Assembling sufficient proof and gaining a conviction in a court of law is an entirely different matter. For some students the highlight of The Sacrificial Cat? is engaging in a mock court situation where the evidence is assembled by the students to secure a probable conviction.

After completing the module, students should have:

  • Had fun
  • Gained new forensic science skills
  • Engaged in difficult, advanced problem solving activities
  • Achieved a great sense of satisfaction having persevered and solved the crime
  • Continued to learn cooperation and sharing skills by working in groups
  • Gained an understanding that the TV series CSI is an artificial environment and the real world is much more difficult
  • Learnt in a relatively unstructured but safe environment
  • Been intellectually challenged
  • Learnt the difference between "knowing" who is the suspect who committed the crime and being able to prove "beyond reasonable doubt" that the suspect is guilty
  • Continued to learn sharing and group skills

Information for schools:

  • A detailed risk management plan has been written and is tailored for each school
  • Assisting supervising teachers do not need to be science trained
  • Briefing notes are given to supervising teachers
  • Logistics - Access to science laboratories desirable but not essential, computers to read an Excel file and a space in which the whole group can meet
  • One day set up prior to the camp; minimal time required post camp
  • Detailed evaluation of student responses conducted.

Go to top

©William Toppin. All Rights reserved. January 2010

Camp Creator:  Mr Kel Hardingham
Original Camp Location:  The Armidale School N.S.W.